The Consequences of Right-Wing Extremism on the Internet
Making Money Online: Selling Goods
Extremists most often try to make money online by
selling extremist versions of common products to other extremists. For
example, instead of spending his money on a New York Yankees jersey at an
online sporting goods store, an extremist might visit the White Heritage
Emporium site to purchase a "White Pride World Wide" T-shirt.
Selling Hate Music
Online, extremists devote more space, time, and
energy to marketing rock music than any other product. The music on hate
rock CDs effectively carries the white supremacist message to teenagers,
and these CDs routinely sell for at least three times the amount they cost
to produce. Because of their popularity among extremist consumers and
their ties to violent extremist organizations, two particular distributors
of hate rock CDs, Resistance Records and Panzerfaust Records, deserve
special attention.
Resistance Records, founded in 1993, sold as many as
50,000 CDs per year before legal troubles led to its decline in 1997. The
remains of Resistance were bought by William Pierce, leader of the
National Alliance, in 1999 (the National Alliance is the largest and most
active neo-Nazi organization in the United States). Pierce reinvigorated
Resistance and predicts gross sales of more than $1 million in 2001. Based
at the West Virginia headquarters of the National Alliance, Resistance
reportedly receives about 50 orders per day, with each order averaging
about $70 worth of merchandise. Many of these orders come via the
well-designed Resistance Web site, which features articles from Resistance
magazine and an online "radio station" that plays songs from the
CDs in its inventory.>
Founded in September 1998 by former Resistance
Records employee Eric Davidson and racist skinhead Anthony, Panzerfaust
Records of Newport, Minnesota financially supports the largest and most
violent racist skinhead group: the Hammerskin Nation. "Panzerfaust
supports Hammerskin Nation 100%," Anthony commented in an interview
with the Hammerskin Nation magazine, Hammerskin Press.
"Together we have put out some great music and Panzerfaust will
always be there to help sponsor and contribute Hammerskin projects and
music."
Panzerfaust and the Hammerskins co-sponsored the
Vinland Tour 2000, featuring Swedish group Pluton Svea, during March 2000
in cities including Detroit and Cleveland, Texas. Hammerskins play in many
of the bands that have recorded for Panzerfaust, and these same bands
perform at concerts sponsored by the Hammerskins. The Panzerfaust Web site
sells CDs by such bands and promotes their concerts. According to Eric
Davidson, "when you support Panzerfaust, you’re not pouring money
into a hole…you’re helping finance a very serious fight."
Marketing Mainstream Items
Not all items sold by extremists online express
extremist beliefs. By carrying products not obviously expressive of their
beliefs, extremists potentially profit from sales to customers who are not
extremists. For example, the Militia of Montana Web site sells common
items such as sleeping bags, compasses, and First Aid kits in addition to
books like "Patriots: Surviving the Coming Collapse," an
important anti-government tome.
Moreover, consumers shopping at Web sites that are
run by extremists but do not carry any items that are evidently extremist
in nature may remain unaware of the politics of the people they are doing
business with. For example, most consumers probably cannot distinguish the
Hammer War Web site, which is run by neo-Nazi Michael Hammer, from
legitimate Web sites that sell German militaria from the Second World War
to collectors and historians. Citing his "passion for military
history," Hammer sells "rare and hard to find" Nazi pins,
postcards, maps, and other items. On his site, he divulges nothing about
his personal views and neither publishes nor sells hate literature. Though
his customers may have no way of knowing it, Michael Hammer in fact
published The New Order, the newsletter of Nebraska neo-Nazi Gary
Lauck, during the four years that Lauck was imprisoned in Germany for
distributing neo-Nazi literature.
Selling Services: Web Design and Web
Hosting
Finally, right-wing extremists use the Internet to
sell not only goods, but also services. Two popular services, Web site
design and Web hosting, simultaneously enrich sellers and help buyers more
effectively spread hate online. Twenty-two year old Kelly Daniels of
Ormond Beach, Florida, heads the most prominent extremist Web site design
team, Candidus Productions. In 1999, he told a reporter that his company
had 15 to 20 customers paying up to $300 each in fees and was "widely
looked upon as being the best in Web design for White Racialism."
According to Candidus Productions, "Regardless of whether you are
selling a product, or trying to get a message out there, a professionally
designed web site is what you NEED to get people to notice you."
Former Klan leader Don Black, proprietor of the Stormfront Web
site, offers space on his Web server to other sites for a $10 to $30
monthly "suggested" contribution. "Stormfront is an
association of White activists on the Internet whose work is partially
supported by providing webhosting for other sites," Black writes.
"With increasing pressure to censor politically unfashionable ideas,
we must work even harder to ensure our point of view continues to be
accessible."
|