March 23, 2000
Next Sunday, 109 million Russian voters will go to polls to elect the
nation's new leader. While acting President Vladimir Putin’s success
appears totally assured, the only questions seem to be about his margin of
victory and how he will rule the nation of 147 million.
In the presence of 10 other contenders, Putin has been the hands-down
favorite of the presidential race ever since this year’s early elections
were announced following Boris Yeltsin’s surprise resignation on Dec.31,
1999.
These days, Russian observers seem to be mostly preoccupied with the
question of whether Putin will be able to garner a 50-percent majority in
the first round of voting or there will be a run-off needed later this
spring.
Recent opinion polls shows that Putin has at least a 50-percent support
base in the March 26 first round, which is far ahead of his nearest rival.
Communist leader Gennady Zyuganov is predicted to receive 15 to 20 percent
of the vote and liberal economist Grigoriy Yavlinsky is likely to garner
support of 5 to 8 percent of Russian electorate.
The 11 candidates in Russia's presidential election are:
- Acting President Vladimir Putin
- Communist leader Gennady Zyuganov
- Governor of the Kemerovo region Aman Tuleev
- Governor of the Samara region Konstantin Titov
- Head of the liberal Yabloko party Grigoriy Yavlinsky
- Businessman Umar Dzhabrailov
- Former assistant to Zyuganov Alexei Podberezkin
- Film director and senior Duma deputy from the centrist
Fatherland-All Russia party Stanislav Govorukhin
- Former chief prosecutor Yuri Skuratov
- Nationalist leader Vladimir Zhirinovsky
- Head of a small centrist group and the first woman to run for the
Russian presidency Ella Pamfilova
(Only three of the candidates took part in the previous presidential
election. Zyuganov, Yavlinsky and Zhirinovsky were respectively second,
fourth and fifth in the previous presidential elections held in 1996.)
Of the 10 contenders (except Putin) five contestants can be described
as holding nationalist views -- Zyuganov, Tuleev, Podberezkin, Govorukhin
and Zhirinovsky. Two -- Titov and Yavlinsky, are prominent members of the
liberal movement who made free economics and human rights issues the core
of their programs. The rest of the contenders are marginal figures who are
expected to receive less than one percent of the vote each.
(Neo-Nazi leader Alexander Barkashov who joined the race earlier this
year was disqualified in February when the Central Election Commission
found some minor technical breaches in his campaign. It is similar to the
situation with the Spas Party, also headed by Barkashov, that following a
major media campaign was not allowed to run in the December 1999 Duma
election when Barkashov was excluded from the race also on technical
grounds.)
A total lack of suspense over the outcome of the vote has turned the
campaigns of all major candidates into an almost useless effort and has
led to apathy on the part of many candidates.
Yet, amidst this year's lackluster election race, the campaigns of
several candidates did resort to nationalist rhetoric which went almost
unnoticed by majority of voters and most of the media outlets.
The use of ultranationalism in election propaganda was part and parcel
of the campaigns of two leading politicians that have long been known for
their anti-Semitic, xenophobic and anti-Western views, Gennady Zyuganov
and Vladimir Zhirinovsky.
In this campaign, Zhirinovsky who seemed to be an extremist character
in previous election campaigns (1991 and 1996) appears to be much more
moderate in his orientation and is not seen this year as representing the
extreme opposition. Zhirinovsky who has shown himself in recent years to
be a loyal supporter of the Kremlin, announced his presidential bid in
order to keep his image of a controversial political fighter. However, he
has no chances, analysts agree, to win a significant portion of the vote.
In an obvious bid to preserve his controversial image, Zhirinovsky said
in an interview earlier this month that he saw himself playing an
equivalent role to Austria's Jorg Haider in Russia if he lost the
presidential election.
The left opposition -- represented in the race by Zyuganov and a couple
of other candidates, is well aware that it has little chances of winning.
Yet with its stable electoral base of 20 to 30 percent, Communists do not
want to lose their face in the eyes of their voters.
Although he refers to the might of Russia when it was the leading power
in the Soviet Union and the Communist bloc, Zyuganov's appeal is more to
Russian's nationalism, summed up in one of his slogans, "For the
victory of Russian patriots!"
This year, the Communists, whose campaigns over the last decade have
always included ultranationalism and Russian chauvinism, again strongly
peppered their election propaganda with xenophobia and anti-Semitism. Most
of Zyuganov’s nationalism is targeted against wealthy and politically
influential entrepreneurs usually referred to as "the
oligarchs," some of whom are known to be of Jewish extraction.
Similar to other opposition politicians, the Communist leader routinely
lashes out at the oligarchs as the new exploiters of Russia and a
"fifth column" in Russian society, disloyal to Russia, and whose
"anti-Russian" activities have been directed from abroad.
In a major political statement outlining his election program and
published in January, Zyuganov made some thinly veiled anti-Semitic
remarks. In an interview with Russia's two leading opposition newspapers,
Sovyetskaya Rossiya and Zavtra, Gennady Zyuganov described results of
Yeltsin’s presidency, saying that Yeltsin left an exhausted, crime-,
poverty- and chaos-stricken country, which over the years of his rule lost
8 million people.
Speaking about the root of Russian problems Zyuganov said that the
country is being "looted" by "a small group of treacherous
bourgeois, oligarchs insatiable in their greed" who act "in the
interest of the U.S.A. and Israel."
On several occasions, Zyuganov also spoke against the proposed
legislation which "blockade national self-consciousness of the
Russian and other peoples that is being done under the false slogans of
fighting Russian fascism." Zyuganov referred to proposed hate crime
legislation, which was blocked by the left majority in the previous Duma,
lower house of Parliament. The draft law "On Political
Extremism" was proposed by liberal lawmakers to bolster the Russian
Criminal Code-based efforts to confront ultranationalism, neo-Nazism and
anti-Semitic extremism.
During this year’s campaign, perhaps to a greater extent than ever
before, Zyuganov's nationalist rhetoric attracted representatives of many
major ultranationalist groups that called on their supporters to back the
Communist leader on March 26. (One notable exception here is Russian
National Unity that urged voters on the eve of the election to vote
against all candidates – an option that exists on Russian election
ballots.)
In one such example, Zyuganov's meeting with voters in southern
Russia's city of Krasnodar last week was dominated by members of neo-Nazi
Russian National Unity organizations and various Cossack groups known for
their xenophobia and anti-Semitism.
Regardless of the outcome of the March 26 vote, this year's
presidential campaign has been used by ultranationalists of all shades to
spread nationalist, anti-Semitic and anti-Western sentiments.
The experience of previous election campaigns already showed that
ultranationalist and xenophobic propaganda is becoming especially active
before the elections regardless of prospects for success for opposition
candidates in the race.
(In one recent example, a group of neo-Nazi skinheads rallied in
downtown Moscow with the formal goal to show support for the presidential
bid of moderate nationalist candidate Alexei Podberezkin who is not likely
to get more than two percent of the vote. In fact, a few dozen of the
participants of the rally on March 23 chanted anti-Semitic slogans and
called on the crowd to beat Jews and dark-skinned people from the
Caucasus.)
One could have noticed this change in the language and content of
leading opposition newspapers, such as Zavtra and Sovyetskya Rossiya,
which took place over the past two months.
(For example, in a recent front page article, Zavtra, a Moscow
ultranationalist weekly newspaper which has an ongoing interest in various
conspiracy theories, alleged that Yeltsin’s resignation and Putin’s
rise to power had come as a result of the thoroughly conceived plot
carried out by Russia’s leading pro-reform politicians of Jewish
extraction, and Goldman Sachs financial group of U.S. which is
"controlled by the Jewish religious capital.")
It should be also noted that xenophobic and nationalist ideas have to
some extent found their way into mainstream politics. Centrist
politicians, including acting President Vladimir Putin, are at times
identifying themselves with the national-patriotic idea and those ideas
develop in the centrist political environment under their own momentum.
This is especially so given Russia's complicated economic situation and
the ongoing war in Chechnya.
In these circumstances, the Jewish community and human rights watchers
should continue to keep a close eye on the ongoing spread of nationalist
and xenophobic propaganda following the next Sunday's vote.
|