Prime Minister Orban's Failure to Challenge Anti-Semitism and Racism
Since assuming office, Orbán has been reluctant to react to István
Csurka's coded or overt anti-Semitic remarks. One current example is the
recent propaganda war waged by Csurka against the choice of Hungarian writers
featured at the Frankfurt book fair. In his party newspaper, Magyar Forum,
Csurka criticized the government for doing nothing about the fact that Hungary
is represented by mostly Jewish authors or topics with Jewish themes at the
Frankfurt fair. Csurka denounced a "Jewish occupation of
literature," "a swamp where non-Jewish writers have no chance to
present their works" and "the dollar-influence of a Lauder-Bronfman-group
which directs all." Neither Orbán nor any spokesman of his government
came out with a statement condemning Csurka's comments.
In another recent incident, after the infamous anti-Semitic tract The
Protocols of the Elders of Zion was published in Hungary, the Federation
of Jewish Communities in Hungary presented a lecture by the Israeli author and
jurist Hadassah Ben-Itto which refuted the tract. Csurka lashed out at the
effort in the media, saying it was an "obstacle to cleaning up and
putting things in order and continues to engage in deception à la Goebbels."
Again, only the Free Democrat Opposition Party (SZDSZ) reacted to Csurka's
comments.
Orbán, who is not believed to be personally anti-Semitic, has said nothing
to denounce anti-Semitic incidents or distance himself from comments made by
the far right, or even by members of his own coalition. His deputy Prime
Minister caused a commotion recently with a strange comment on the
"Jewish Question." Orbán knows he would alienate some of his
supporters by speaking out and therefore he and members of his ruling
coalition defend themselves against criticism for not denouncing extremists by
playing the "democracy" card everyone is entitled to his or her
opinion and freedom of speech, etc.
Orbán's own precarious political situation has made any strong statement
against anti-Semitism unlikely. A year after ousting the Horn government, his
popularity has dramatically declined: He is far from fulfilling his election
promises and therefore the electorate has become disillusioned with him.
Moreover, the feeling prevails that he is more concerned with "bashing
the Socialists" than working for the general good of the country. If
there were elections today, the running gag is that Orbán would win elections
anywhere other than at home. Furthermore, there are rumors of corruption and
nepotism connected to Orbán in the country's privatization effort. He has
also brutally dismissed and appointed diplomats, cultural attachés and
high-ranking media people to fit his political agenda.
Despite the current poor press, Orbán believes he can win the 2002
elections by uniting the right bloc in Hungary (FIDESZ leading a conservative
right group consisting of MDF, the Smallholders of Torgyan and, eventually,
splinters of Csurka's MIEP). The complicated Hungarian election system may
bring him close to this goal: Already in 1998, he could only gain votes in
decisive regions because Torgyan and Csurka struck a deal and recommended
FIDESZ. To ensure this support, Orbán cannot afford to alienate the right.
Next: Jewish Community Reaction & Recent Anti-Semitism
|