Jewish Community Reaction and Recent Anti-Semitism
The Jewish community has often been conflicted as to how best to combat
anti-Semitism in Hungary. Many of the community's "old guard" have
long believed that protesting anti-Semitic comments by Csurka and others would
only serve to give these individuals greater national exposure. Under the
newly elected head of the Hungarian Federation of Jewish Communities, Peter
Tordai, the community has become more active. Tordai has had several meetings
with the Prime Minister voicing the concern of the Federation regarding the
surging of verbal anti-Semitism in daily life, especially as manifested by
Csurka. Orbán repeatedly appeased Tordai, claiming that he had everything
under control.
Meanwhile, the community is assembling legislation that would provide a
benchmark for what constitutes hate crimes and anti-minority incitement as well as
criminalizing Holocaust denial and crimes against humanity. This proposal was
submitted to Parliament on October 15.
Recent Anti-Semitic Incidents:
February 1999: Neo-Nazis again commemorated the "Day of
Pride." Eight skinheads attacked policemen with pieces of furniture while
shouting Nazi slogans such as "Sieg Heil." These eight skinheads
were arrested; 30 others were expelled. As a reaction to this incident, Prime
Minister Viktor Orbán promised to crack down on "neo-fascist rowdyism."
March 1999: On March 15, the Hungarian National Bank Holiday, the
"Association for the Welfare of the Hungarian People" (Verband der
ungarischen Volkswohlfahrt) held a public rally under the supervision of the
police. Their leader, Albert Szabo, publicly destroyed a Star of David as well
as a NATO emblem, which he referred to as symbols "for misanthropic
inhuman actions enforced under the banner of Zionism." He also wished the
Iraqi people well in their fight against "those Zionistic pigs."
On the very same day, skinheads, as well as fans of the Ferencvaros soccer
team, yelled anti-Semitic slogans during a football match while the leader of
the Smallholders Party, Joszef Torgyan, and the Minister of Sports, Tamas
Deutsch, watched the match calmly in the grandstand.
July 1999: A major Jewish cemetery in the Hungarian town of
Szombathely was desecrated. Nazi swastikas, the Star of David hanging from
gallows and obscene drawings were smeared onto gravestones. The Hungarian
President, Arpad Goencz, condemned the incident in an unusually clear comment
to the press:
First, the desecration of a cemetery is a police affair. The perpetrators
must be found and must be taken to court. Secondly, this is a moral issue.
This was carefully planned, rude sacrilege which is being rejected by a vast
majority of the Hungarian public. Thirdly, it is a social issue we must
honestly face and examine in a wider context. In the fourth place, it is an
international issue: How can the European public, which tends to generalize,
harmonize such doings with the picture of a Hungary which wants to join Europe
and wants to accomplish social democracy? Fifth, it automatically raises the
question of how we can avoid such insinuation phenomena. They can only be
avoided if they meet with clear and open rejection from both the state and the
society, the entire range of the media which shape public opinion and from
both political sides. Otherwise, we all universally have to take
responsibility in front of the world and what is worse in front of ourselves.
August 1999: The Jewish community filed a court challenge following
the publication of The Protocols of the Elders of Zion. They are still
awaiting the results of the police investigation into whether the publisher is
in fact violating Hungarian law by "inciting hatred" against a
community.
September 1999: The Council of Europe branded two of the six parties
in Hungary's Parliament including the junior coalition partner, the
Smallholders as "extremist."
The National Police submitted an indictment to the Capital Prosecutor
General's Office against Aron Mónus for publishing Hitler's Mein Kampf
without permission. The Federation of Jewish Religious Communities in Hungary
reported Mónus to the authorities two years ago for publishing the book.
Plans to revamp a Hungarian-sponsored exhibit at Auschwitz came under
attack for failing to document Hungarian compliance with the Nazi murder of
600,000 Hungarian Jews. In solely blaming the Nazis for Jewish deportations
and extermination, Jewish leaders accused Hungary of failing to confront its
history. The Orbán government had originally planned to revamp the exhibit
installed in 1965 because of its focus on the Communist victory over the
Third Reich.
October 1999: István Csurka was the lone politician in Central
Europe to praise Joerg Haider for his anti-immigrant Freedom Party's stunning
performance in the Austrian elections.
In another affront to the 100,000 or so Jews still living in Hungary,
right-wing politicians unveiled a plaque dedicated to the memory of the
Hungarian royal police who died during the two world wars. However, the plaque
made no mention that it was mainly these police who, after the German
occupation on March 19, 1944, efficiently carried out orders to round up
Hungarian Jews from the countryside. In seven weeks, they herded 437,000 Jews
into ghettoes and then deported them to various death camps. Hungarian Jews
are especially sensitive about the issue of war memorials because no
administration here has ever built a monument to its murdered Jews.
|