Two Faiths, But One Mind on Keeping Politics Out of the Pews

By Rabbi David Fox Samdel | Director of Interreligious Engagement & Rev. Dr. Susan Henry-Crowe | General Secretary of the General Board of Church and Society of The United Methodist Church
  • December 7, 2017
    This article originally appeared in

We come from two different faiths, but we and many other religious and denominational organizations are in absolute agreement that Congress must uphold one of the fundamental principles of our great country: the separation between church and state. Unfortunately, the pending tax bill would reverse this separation — which was so important to our Founders that they enshrined it in the Constitution’s First Amendment. And it has remained an essential part of American democracy for more than 225 years.

Both the House and Senate tax bills would repeal the Johnson Amendment, sponsored by then-Sen. Lyndon Johnson (D-Texas) and enacted in 1954 to prohibit all churches and 501(c)(3) nonprofit organizations from endorsing or opposing political candidates.

It’s hard to believe that we need to convince the Congress to keep our most fundamental freedom — religious freedom for all people — but let us be clear: senators must stand up for this bedrock American principle.

Roger Williams, who founded the first Baptist church in America, wrote in 1644 that there should be a “wall of separation between the garden of the church and the wilderness of the world.” Those words inspired Thomas Jefferson’s view that there should be an unambiguous separation between church and state.

The separation of church and state is designed to protect both and must be maintained. We should not in any way weaken the foundations of the wall, or we will seriously damage the integrity and independence of houses of worship.

When the tens of millions of Americans attend their houses of worship, they do so to pray and worship in fellowship with their families and communities. They come to heal and restore hope. They come to put aside the divisive world outside and focus on making themselves and their communities better.

We need to keep the Johnson Amendment’s critical protections, or we will be inviting inappropriate religious entanglement with electoral politics, campaign donations and special interests.

Repeal would encourage divisive manipulation of religious organizations by campaign donors who are not subject to customary campaign finance laws — a process that could make politicians beholden to religious majorities and darken the transparency of the electoral process.

That’s why over 100 religious and denominational organizations — representing Baptists, Catholics, Episcopalians, Jews, Lutherans, Methodists, Muslims, Presbyterians, Sikhs and others  — have urged the leaders of the House and Senate and the tax committees to keep the law intact.

Our nation needs a meaningful Johnson Amendment to protect democratic values and maintain the separation of church and state.

The need for separation that Williams wrote about is even more important today given the state of our “wilderness.” Our society is already challenging enough for people of faith without bringing partisan politics into our pews. Congress, please don’t inject politics into our houses of worship.

More from this Section