Related Content
Antisemitism in the Healthcare Workforce
Antisemitism in Medical Schools
Introduction
For many patients, entering a hospital or other medical setting can provoke significant anxiety and apprehension, often stemming from uncertainty about a potential diagnosis, anticipation of invasive procedures or the prospect of undergoing high-risk medical interventions. For Jewish patients, an additional set of fears and anxieties enter the scene: Will this doctor still provide me with high-quality medical care if they find out that I am Jewish? If I need to stay at the hospital over the weekend, will I be able to observe Shabbat and receive kosher food? Together, these fears and considerations reflect the broader risk calculus that Jewish patients often find themselves running when selecting doctors or deciding where to receive medical treatment.
When graduating from medical school, newly minted doctors recite the Hippocratic Oath, a commitment to treat all patients fairly and equally. Physicians have a duty to treat patients regardless of whether they can pay for healthcare and irrespective of their demographic backgrounds or political beliefs. Healthcare institutions also have legal obligations under several federal laws to prevent discrimination. Recent HHS guidance reinforces these protections, including against discrimination rooted in antisemitism. When physicians fail to fully uphold these ideals, the healthcare system falls short and undermines the trust between providers and patients.
This report begins to surface critical gaps in the treatment and delivery of care to Jewish patients in the U.S. healthcare system, based on 40 interviews with Jewish people who have received healthcare services in the U.S. within the past five years. Participants described experiences of overt hostility toward Jewish identity while accessing healthcare, as well as broader concerns about bias, exclusion and feeling unsafe because of their Jewish identity in healthcare settings.
They reflected on how these experiences shaped their confidence in healthcare providers, their willingness to disclose their Jewish identity, and their trust that healthcare institutions would provide equitable care. They also identified opportunities for healthcare organizations to strengthen inclusion, accountability, and patient confidence.
The findings highlight the responsibility of healthcare organizations to ensure that Jewish patients, and all patients, can access healthcare with confidence that they will be treated with dignity, respect, and without discrimination. They also point to a clear path forward: Hospitals, health systems, medical schools, clinics, and other healthcare institutions should adopt ADL and AJMA’s Five Asks for Hospitals and Healthcare Institutions, which provide a concrete framework for confronting antisemitism, strengthening institutional accountability, and fostering healthcare environments where Jewish patients and healthcare professionals feel safe, supported, and respected. By translating these recommendations into meaningful policies and practices, healthcare institutions can move beyond statements of commitment to create lasting, measurable change.
*Patients reading this report should review ADL and AJMA’s Know Your Rights – Patients fact sheet.
Topline findings
- Fear of disclosing Jewish identity to healthcare providers has intensified since October 7th
Participants described withholding or downplaying their Jewish identity on hospital intake forms, avoiding wearing overt displays of Jewish identity in clinical settings, and remaining guarded about disclosing their Jewish identity until they could fully assess the potential biases of their healthcare providers. A number of participants expressed feeling a heightened sense of caution around disclosing Jewish identity to medical providers ever since the October 7, 2023, Hamas-led terrorist attack on Israel and as a result of the surge in antisemitism they have observed in recent years.
Experiences varied, with some Jewish patients having the opposite reaction, becoming more openly Jewish since October 7, and some feeling no need to conceal their Jewish identity at all. While experiences are not uniform and Jewish patients differ in what they decide to conceal or reveal to healthcare providers, the problem lies in the fact that Jewish patients are faced with making this risk calculus at all.
- Jewish patients report a range of hospital experiences, from barriers to religious accommodations and overt hostility to examples of meaningful inclusion
Interviews revealed significant variation in how healthcare institutions accommodate Jewish patients’ religious and cultural needs. Participants described barriers to accessing kosher food and Jewish chaplains, friction around Shabbat observance, and, in extreme cases, overt hostility from medical providers regarding their Jewish identity or participation in rituals such as brit milah (Jewish ritual circumcision). However, participants also highlighted hospitals that successfully accommodate Jewish patients through on-staff rabbis, kosher food options, and Shabbat elevators. These contrasting experiences demonstrate that while barriers to Jewish inclusion can be both administrative and interpersonal, meaningful religious and cultural accommodation is achievable when hospitals prioritize institutional support and cultural awareness.
- Healthcare provider selection is often shaped by concerns about perceived biases related to Jewish identity, not just clinical quality
Participants often said they felt a need to avoid certain providers based on factors beyond their clinical abilities and experience, such as the provider’s perceived politics or perceptions of Jews and Israel. Where feasible, a number of participants actively sought out Jewish doctors, based on an underlying assumption of mutual trust. The selection of a medical provider is a deeply personal decision shaped by many factors. Concerningly, for Jewish patients, this often includes making a judgement call about whether the provider may hold biases against them as a demographic group and how such biases could influence the delivery of high-quality healthcare.
- Jewish patients point to specific changes that would help them feel safer
When asked what could be done to improve the experience of Jewish patients in healthcare settings, participants often recommended structural solutions, such as formal antisemitism and anti-bias training for hospital staff, greater availability of rabbis in addition to other chaplains, and offering kosher dining options. Several participants underscored the need for greater enforcement of existing codes of conduct in healthcare institutions, and a number of participants referenced the Hippocratic Oath and its modern equivalents, which embody some of the most fundamental principles of medical ethics: the duties to do no harm and to provide care fairly, impartially, and without discrimination, regardless of a patient’s demographic identity.
1. Fear of disclosing Jewish identity to healthcare providers has intensified since October 7
The participants in this study often described feeling a need to refrain from disclosing their Jewish identity to medical providers, typically out of fear and concern that their providers may be biased against Jews. In multiple cases, participants emphasized that these anxieties around revealing their Jewish identity to medical providers have escalated since the October 7 Hamas-led terrorist attack on Israel. These accounts suggest that disclosing Jewish identity was not always experienced as a neutral act of sharing personal information, but rather as a decision that could introduce an additional layer of vulnerability into an already unequal patient-provider relationship. In this context, the possibility of encountering bias, even in the absence of direct evidence that a particular provider held antisemitic views, was sometimes sufficient to shape participants' behavior.
Often, concerns around whether to disclose Jewish identity stem from a fear of receiving unequal, or lower quality, treatment. This heightened sense of vulnerability reflects the broader surge in antisemitism across American Jewish and other Jewish diaspora communities following October 7, with 2025 being the third-highest year on record for antisemitic incidents in the U.S. since the ADL began tracking them in 1979 and the deadliest year for antisemitic attacks outside Israel in over three decades. The extension of vigilance into medical settings also illustrates how experiences and perceptions of antisemitism in the broader social environment can undermine trust in institutions that patients may have previously regarded as safe spaces.
As one participant explained, “I'm not comfortable disclosing that I'm Jewish...I worry about the kind of care I would get." One interviewee underscored that medical providers have a legal duty to treat all patients equally, but expressed that, nonetheless, it remains plausible and concerning that providers may still treat Jewish patients or patients from other marginalized groups with lower quality care: "[I]n this country, treating somebody with inferior care because of what you consider to be their...religious affiliation...it would be illegal, but the thing is...that you can do things like that."
Another participant explained that they have begun to conceal their Jewish identity ever since experiencing antisemitism and expressed concern about the type of treatment they may receive:
“I’ve had some experiences over the years where I have felt antisemitism...I did not want to compromise the quality of the care I was receiving or put myself in danger of having something bad happen to me in the hospital and so I don’t remember exactly at what point, probably not long after October 7th, 2023, I did have an ER visit where I did experience significant antisemitism and at that point, I began removing my religion from all hospitals that I visited from that point forward.”
Focusing on the impacts of October 7, one participant noted that disclosing her Jewish identity “was never an issue...I don't think it was ever an issue until October 7th. I never really thought about it." Similarly, another interviewee explained that being increasingly cautious about disclosing her Jewish identity extends well beyond the medical sphere and impacts the ways she navigates the current world more broadly, "[Since October 7], I'm definitely a lot more guarded in everything I do but definitely as a patient."
Other participants specifically described that feeling a need to conceal their Jewish identity in interactions with medical providers stems not only from the events of October 7, but also the broader rise in antisemitism in recent years. For instance, one participant described how the recent surge in antisemitism has led her to only raise that she is Jewish on an as-needed basis in medical settings:
“I've seen an increase in antisemitism in the past few years...In fact, there was a Nazi rally in a park [near] my house...I tend not to advertise what I am. If there's a form and the hospital, for example, asks for my religious affiliation, I will put that, but I don't walk into a doctor's office and say 'hey, I'm Jewish.' You know, if it comes up, I don't hide it, but I don't volunteer it.”
Relatedly, another participant explained that, where she lives, her experiences have led her to be more guarded around revealing her Jewish identity to medical providers: "I don't feel very comfortable [disclosing my Jewish identity to medical providers] at all...[where I live] I have encountered...visible like instances of...opposition...that also takes the frame of...anti-Israeli...or anti-Jewish sentiment, so I am very careful...I try not to overtly disclose that."
These accounts illustrate how patients' assessments of safety within healthcare settings may be influenced by experiences that occur entirely outside of them. Participants' perceptions of hostility within their surrounding communities appear to inform their expectations of medical providers, suggesting that trust in healthcare does not develop independently of the broader social and political environments in which patients live.
Although multiple participants described feeling a need to conceal their Jewish identity in medical interactions, others felt less guarded about it. It is important to note, however, that differences in levels of religious observance may influence the extent to which patients need to disclose their Jewish identity in healthcare settings.
As one participant said, "I've never had to really identify myself as Jewish to get healthcare, but I wouldn't have a problem identifying myself as such." In some cases, the decision of whether to disclose one’s Jewish identity depended in part on whether the provider was Jewish. One participant explained, “I'd say I think if I like get the impression that the person providing the healthcare is also Jewish, I'm more inclined to offer up that information...I don't think there is an example of a time when I've really hesitated to say out loud that...I'm Jewish in a healthcare environment." This participant also explained how they went through a period of time in which they hesitated to wear overt identifiers of Jewish identity, but subsequently decided to instead be more vocal and proud of showing that they are Jewish:
“I have probably been more vocal about being Jewish since October [7]...There was a period of time when I was like, well, should I wear my...Jewish stars, should I or should I not?...I've probably leaned in harder to being more explicitly and blatantly Jewish and...vocally Jewish than I had previously...like not wanting people to be able to hide from their biases.”
Another noted “I’m not gonna say that I haven’t experienced antisemitism from healthcare providers in healthcare settings. But I’m not going to be hiding my Jewish identity...I’m just gonna be like f**k it and field it when it comes.”
These accounts demonstrate how antisemitism, both within and beyond healthcare settings, can undermine Jewish patients’ sense of safety and trust in medical providers. Although participants differed in their willingness to disclose their Jewish identity, their experiences reveal how concerns about antisemitism can shape even the most basic aspects of patient-provider interactions. The central issue is not whether Jewish patients choose to conceal or openly express their identity, but that they are placed in a position where they must consider whether being Jewish could compromise the quality of care they receive. These findings underscore that the consequences of antisemitism extend beyond overt acts of discrimination, creating an additional burden for Jewish patients in settings where they should be able to expect safety, dignity, and equitable treatment.
2. Jewish patients report a range of hospital experiences, from barriers to religious accommodations and overt hostility to examples of meaningful inclusion
Participants in this study described a range of experiences in medical settings, with numerous describing interactions with medical providers that they perceived as overtly hostile toward their Jewish identity or religious practices. Recent research on antisemitism in healthcare substantiates this finding. For instance, a recent narrative review identified studies documenting high levels of antisemitism, particularly in medical education, psychology, and social work. Similarly, in the United Kingdom, an independent review commissioned by the Department of Health and Social Care highlighted the seriousness of antisemitism within the National Health Service (NHS). The review's author, Lord Mann, stated: “I have heard evidence of routine ostracism of Jewish people, continuous negativity to people because of their identity, extreme behaviours including serious race hate incidents, and related consequences.”
Our research also revealed significant variation in how healthcare institutions accommodate and respond to Jewish patients’ religious and cultural needs. Some participants encountered significant administrative shortcomings, including inadequate kosher food options, limited access to Jewish spiritual support, and difficulties observing religious holidays. Others described interactions with medical providers that they perceived as overtly hostile toward their Jewish identity or religious practices.
At the same time, several participants reported positive experiences at hospitals that made meaningful efforts to accommodate their religious needs. Together, these accounts illustrate both the challenges Jewish patients can face and the potential for healthcare institutions to foster environments in which Jewish patients feel respected and supported.
Overt Hostility and Discrimination
Throughout the interview, participants described experiences that they perceived as hostility from medical providers after their Jewish identity became known. One participant recalled a particularly noticeable shift in an employee’s demeanor during a hospital admission:
“This person had entered my room all smiles and jovial and warm and friendly...when she came to the question of what is your religion I said ‘Jewish’ and she turned to ice...her questions were short and curt... a total switch in her behavior.”
Similarly, another participant described receiving an ultrasound during which “[the healthcare provider] saw I do wear a very large Star of David and I had forgotten to take it off. So it was very obvious when...she saw it, she was very rude...she was unnecessarily rough, one-word answers, questions...I did report it to the front desk and then they said they were going to write it down, someone was going to reach out to me. No one's reached out to me.”
In both accounts, participants described a noticeable deterioration in how they were treated immediately after their Jewish identities became known. These experiences illustrate how hostility toward Jewish patients can manifest not only through explicit antisemitic remarks, but also through changes in providers’ demeanor, attentiveness, communication, and even physical treatment. Such behavior can, in turn, undermine patients’ dignity, sense of safety, and trust in their medical providers.
Other participants described tensions arising around Jewish religious rituals, particularly brit milah, the ritual circumcision traditionally performed on the eighth day after the birth of a Jewish boy. One participant recalled that, after informing their child's pediatrician that the family had held a bris at home, the doctor's previously warm and attentive demeanor changed:
“From that moment on, the doctor was kind of cold with us, and... didn't want to answer our questions very much.”
The participant explained that the family had originally chosen the pediatrician because he was responsive and willing to spend time answering questions. Following the disclosure, however, they felt he became increasingly dismissive, leaving them uncomfortable with the care their child was receiving. The participant also noted that “from that moment on, we tried to switch doctors but weren't able to, everyone was full up, so he became very dismissive,” underscoring how Jewish patients can find themselves stuck receiving care from providers who have treated them with hostility, particularly when alternative providers are unavailable.
Another participant described a similar experience in which their doctor repeatedly emphasized that circumcision was not medically necessary, saying “there's no medical reason for that,” even after they explained its religious significance. They recalled telling the doctor, “that's fine, it's tradition, I'm Jewish,” and the doctor again responding “well, it's not medically necessary.”
These encounters illustrate tensions that can arise when medical providers approach Jewish religious practices without adequately acknowledging their religious significance. While discussing the medical necessity of a procedure is appropriate, these participants felt that their religious traditions were being dismissed or judged rather than respectfully incorporated into the conversation.
In more extreme cases, participants described medical encounters involving overtly hostile statements or political discussions that left them feeling vulnerable. One participant recounted an experience during an acupuncture appointment in which the provider unexpectedly began discussing the Israeli-Palestinian conflict after identifying her as Jewish. Reflecting on the incident, the participant recounted that:
“[The acupuncturist] started to say that Israelis are baby killers... and I said, ‘I don't agree with that.’ I was like, ‘I get...tensions are high, and I understand this is a very divisive issue, but this is something that's been happening for a long time.’ She says, ‘you're a baby killer, you're a baby killer, you're okay with this?’”
The participant emphasized the vulnerability of being confronted in this way while undergoing treatment: “Meanwhile, like, I have needles in my body, right? I can't just get up and leave.”
This account illustrates how the introduction of hostile political accusations into a medical encounter can leave patients feeling particularly powerless when they are physically dependent on a provider to complete their treatment.
Similarly, another participant described feeling uncomfortable during a required hospital appointment while being evaluated as a potential kidney donor. The participant encountered a non-Palestinian social worker wearing a keffiyeh, which the participant viewed as a potentially political statement in the aftermath of October 7, especially as the employee was not Palestinian. When the patient requested another provider, they were told that no alternative was available, and their subsequent complaints went unanswered. Reflecting on the incident, the participant stated: “It's your job to have made the space more comfortable. She didn't offer to take it off. She told me there wasn't anyone else I could talk to... she didn't respond to my email.” This experience highlights how the lack of alternative providers and institutional responsiveness can leave patients with little choice but to continue medical interactions in which they feel uncomfortable or unsafe.
Another participant described an emergency department experience in which they felt that a nurse was dismissive, failed to respond to their questions, and did not provide adequate care:
“A little over a month after the October 7th attacks... I was feeling very lightheaded. I didn't know what was wrong with me. I was extremely nauseous... this nurse... was very curt with me, very, non-responsive... never even answered my questions, just, like, wouldn't even talk to me... They drew blood. It turned out in the end that... my TSH was extraordinarily low...and when those results came back, I asked her... ‘is there anything wrong with my TSH? Because I don't know why I feel like that.’ She's like, ‘no.’ And I didn't find out until later, when I saw the results myself, that that was absolutely what was wrong...She put me into a room that was completely not cleaned and smelled like urine... I didn't ask her if she was being antisemitic... but I got an incredibly strong sense that that's what it was.”
The encounter had lasting consequences for their willingness to disclose their Jewish identity in medical settings: “I proactively took my religion off of any medical records that I could, because I didn't want to be in that situation again...I don't want to compromise my safety.”
A separate participant described feeling deeply unsettled by their surgeon’s conduct prior to undergoing surgery:
“I was prepping to go into surgery... one of the doctors... had multiple Free Palestine pins on her lanyard... one of them had a map of Israel, the country where I was born... in the colors of the Palestinian flag... what that means to me is that she doesn't think I should be born there... I felt scared... if I think that this person has cause to wish me harm... Might they make a mistake? Might they slip?... this didn't alter the care I received, but the fact that I was put in this situation was very shocking to me... And since then, I've been very, very cautious.”
Another participant noted that medical aides were “very rough” with a patient the participant was taking care of, stating: “They knew he was from Israel, and they were a little hostile, I thought.”
Although these experiences varied in nature and severity, they raised broader concerns about whether Jewish patients could openly express their identities and religious practices without fearing prejudice or changes in the quality of care they received. They also illustrate the importance of distinguishing between a provider's intentions, which patients may not be able to establish, and the effects that perceived hostility can have on patients’ trust and sense of safety.
Lacking Religious Accommodations
Multiple participants expressed dissatisfaction with hospital religious accommodations for Jewish patients, such as a lack of kosher food and limited or no availability of Jewish chaplains. As one participant described, "in looking over the daily menus, I don't recall that they were able to provide kosher meals." Similarly, another participant expressed, "[where I live] they don't do kosher meals in the hospitals if you keep kosher." One interviewee described the hospital’s lack of awareness around different kashrut labels, as different Jewish communities adhere to different labels and standards of what is kosher, and a severe case where they mislabeled pork as kosher:
“Since I keep kosher, I brought a lot of food and snacks and...I explained to them that I keep kosher and when I registered ahead of time, I noted it on the intake form and they brought me a bunch of boxed meals that were like Tablet K or something, or Triangle K and I was like, 'I know that this is...that it says it's kosher, but I'm really sorry, I actually don't eat these' and then he kept bringing them and then finally the third or fourth time, they brought me a tray from the dining hall that was pork loin and it said kosher on the meal ticket.”
In addition to lack of kosher food, participants also described a lack of rabbis and chaplains equipped to support Jewish patients spiritually and religiously in hospital settings. One participant described having surgery at a hospital where a chaplain was present but was noticeably uncomfortable talking to her because she was Jewish:
“When I've had my recent surgeries...the hospital where I've had my surgeries is a Seventh-day Adventist Hospital...I'll tell them I'm Jewish and I know that later on...the chaplain is going to come see me...I know that from my experience, he's always very uncomfortable in talking with me because he knows I'm Jewish.”
Furthermore, in some cases, hospitals lacked sufficient accommodations for patients who observe Shabbat, such as not being able to delay discharge timing until after Shabbat ends:
“On Friday morning...the doctor came in and said 'I need you to stay one more night' and I said, 'okay, well...if I'm staying tonight it's Sabbath, I can't leave until Saturday night at 9PM so...I would have to be there all day to be discharged late at night.' And they were like 'okay it's fine' and then on Saturday morning, the nurse came in and said, 'alright, the doctor looked and is gonna discharge you now.' And I was like, 'I can't leave, it's Shabbat and we already went over this.' And they were like 'sorry, you have to go, we are totally overbooked with beds.'”
Another participant described having her son being discharged from a hospital on Yom Kippur and the staff were completely unaware of the tone and observance of the holiday such that they wished them a “Happy Yom Kippur!” highlighting a lack of awareness of Jewish religious practices. The participant explained, “Not only did they discharge [my son] on Yom Kippur, every single person who came to say goodbye said ‘oh, it’s Yom Kippur’...They don’t know what Yom Kippur is, like ‘Happy Yom Kippur!’”
These experiences suggest that shortcomings in religious accommodation extend beyond the availability of particular services or resources. They also reflect gaps in institutional understanding of Jewish religious practices and in the consistency with which patients' needs are acknowledged and respected across different members of hospital staff.
When Hospitals Get It Right
In addition to revealing gaps in how healthcare institutions accommodate the needs of Jewish patients, this study’s interviews also revealed a variety of positive counterexamples of hospitals making the effort to ensure that Jewish patients have the spiritual and religious support that they need. Some participants described going to hospitals where they felt comfortable with and supported by the available chaplains, such as one interviewee who explained:
“Our local hospital is a Catholic hospital...On occasions when I've been hospitalized, sometimes they have a rabbi on staff at the hospital but sometimes a priest will come in a room. And I'm always delighted to have a discussion with the priest.”
Another participant described receiving strong spiritual care from a non-Jewish chaplain, explaining, "Last year, I was in a Catholic hospital and the chaplain came in and gave out a pamphlet with Jewish prayers."
Furthermore, spiritual and religious support for Jewish patients can be a relevant and essential source of comfort in all phases of life, but perhaps especially when receiving end-of-life care. One participant reflected favorably on the quality of spiritual care that her family received when her husband was in hospice: "there was a chaplain that came by who was prepared to do Jewish prayers and observances. We had the rabbi come, but it was nice...that they were able to facilitate that."
These positive experiences receiving spiritual support from chaplains in non-Jewish hospital settings demonstrate that creating an inclusive environment for Jewish patients does not necessarily depend on a hospital’s religious affiliation or access to Jewish chaplains. Rather, they underscore the importance of ensuring that chaplains are equipped with the cultural and religious knowledge necessary to understand and respond sensitively to Jewish patients’ needs, allowing them to provide meaningful spiritual support across religious differences.
In some cases, participants had received care at hospitals that offered spiritual support and religious accommodations that were specific to Jewish patients. For instance, one participant described going to a hospital that had multiple rabbis on staff: "The system I get most of my healthcare in has rabbis on staff and they've, as long as I can remember, they've had at least one rabbi. Occasionally, 2 or 3 rabbis on their chaplain staff. So they are very...inclusive." Additionally, a participant mentioned having received care at a hospital that had a number of Jewish religious accommodations, namely "people [in the hospital]...who were kosher could get food...on Shabbat and [there's a]...Shabbat elevator."
These participants’ experiences receiving high quality spiritual and religious support reveal that accommodating Jewish patients’ spiritual and religious needs in the delivery of healthcare is well within reach for hospitals and other medical institutions. When inclusion is taken seriously, Jewish patients can find comfort and support in healthcare settings even when they are facing difficult medical circumstances.
These interviews reveal a striking divide in Jewish patients’ experiences across healthcare settings. While some patients encountered barriers to basic religious accommodations or feared that disclosing their Jewish identity could compromise their care, others described hospitals where their religious and cultural needs were understood, respected, and accommodated. These contrasting experiences demonstrate that meaningful Jewish inclusion is not an unattainable ideal, but an achievable standard that some institutions have already embraced. Ensuring that Jewish patients feel safe and respected requires more than isolated acts of sensitivity; it demands institutional commitment to religious accommodation, cultural awareness, and consistent nondiscrimination in everyday clinical interactions. Ultimately, Jewish patients should not have to question whether their identity or religious practices will affect the quality of care they receive, particularly when they are most vulnerable and dependent on the healthcare system.
3. Healthcare provider selection is often shaped by concerns about perceived biases related to Jewish identity, not just clinical quality
Another troubling theme that surfaced during interviews was Jewish patients feeling a need to avoid certain healthcare providers based on factors beyond their clinical abilities, such as their real or perceived perceptions of Jews and Israel. In a number of cases, participants described actively seeking out Jewish healthcare providers. One participant explained that when she was selecting a doctor for her son, she thought, “she’s Jewish and that totally swayed me...” Similarly, another participant said, "I definitely like seeing Jewish doctors in general.” One participant described the sense of mutual connection that having a Jewish doctor can provide:
“I have had positive experiences as a Jewish patient connecting with other…
connecting with Jewish doctors, you know, relating to the experience.”
One participant explained that for them, the process of seeking to identify the potential biases of healthcare providers is a first step in selecting a physician, "This is one of the first questions...I try to suss out...when I pick my healthcare providers. I try to kind of do my best estimation about whether they are likely to...treat me fairly." Relatedly, another participant emphasized having concerns about how providers’ biases may actually impact their delivery of healthcare to patients,
“[B]ecause of the fact that people are biased, I assume that they carry those biases into their jobs. I haven't experienced...open bias...I know that a lot of bias is covert rather than overt. And as a patient, I rely on the providers to do what's right and tell me what's right...do people's biases impact what they do professionally? I think probably sometimes.”
The ability to find and select a Jewish healthcare provider is location dependent. For instance, one participant described living in a place where finding a Jewish provider was easy, "we have a [large] professional Jewish population [where I live] so it's not challenging to find a Jewish doctor, but it definitely does impact my choice." By contrast, another participant explained how living in an area with a relatively small Jewish community can make it uncomfortable to select a Jewish provider specifically, as the chances of running into them in local Jewish community settings is high:
“It's very hard living in an extremely small Jewish community because I am very uncomfortable seeing the provider in like a public setting at, for example, a Jewish event...I know that some people don't mind it at all, they like having that relationship outside of the doctor-patient setting, but I found out that I don't...I like to have that separation.”
It can also be challenging to even find a Jewish healthcare provider when living in an area with a small Jewish population. As one participant said, “it’s really hard to find Jewish providers [where I live].” Furthermore, one participant expressed concern about seeing doctors who were recent medical school graduates, given the protest activity that has occurred on campuses in the U.S. since October 7 and the potential biases that these new physicians may hold:
“If [the doctor] was like a young person who had just recently graduated med school...I wouldn't necessarily want them to know I was Jewish...I just think there's been such generational change, not just in healthcare, but in the ways that Jewish [and] Israel are perceived...I've read about things...taking place on medical school campuses where there have been protests by the future doctors that will be caring for us, so that really scares me...would they deny my care if they found out that I was Jewish?”
Such concerns are particularly consequential for patients already undergoing treatment, as disruptions in established patient-provider relationships can jeopardize continuity of care. Recognizing these risks, many states have laws and regulations protecting patients against abrupt discontinuation of care, generally requiring reasonable notice and an opportunity to arrange alternative treatment.
Although concerns about physicians’ potential biases related to Jews and Israel factored into some participants’ selection of healthcare providers, this was not the case for all participants. As one participant described, whether a provider is Jewish "has not been a factor in who I seek for...medical attention...the medical professionals I have encountered have been fair, neutral, biases are not shown."
Some participants also described having positive and supportive experiences with non-Jewish providers, with one saying, “I’ve had wonderful doctors who aren’t Jewish. Sometimes I guess I would feel a little more safe if I knew they were Jewish. But I don’t exclusively seek out Jewish doctors."
Selecting a medical provider is a deeply personal decision shaped by a range of considerations, including trust, comfort, and confidence in the quality of care. For some Jewish patients interviewed in this study, however, this decision involved an additional consideration: whether a prospective provider might harbor biases against Jews and, if so, whether those biases could affect the care they receive. These accounts illustrate how concerns about antisemitism can shape Jewish patients’ healthcare decisions before they even enter a medical setting, introducing an additional burden into the process of finding a provider they can trust.
4. Jewish patients point to specific changes that would help them feel safer
When asked what could be done to improve the experience of Jewish patients in healthcare settings, participants mentioned a variety of accommodations and structural changes that would make them feel safer and more included in these settings. A number of participants emphasized the need for greater availability of rabbis in clinical settings. One participant explained that this would not necessarily mean that the hospital must hire a full-time rabbi, but should at least have a designated rabbi they can call when needed, "I think...it would be helpful for the hospitals to not only have a chaplain on staff but [also] have a rabbi on staff or have a rabbi that they can reach out and contact." Another participant suggested that when having a round-the-clock rabbi on staff is not feasible, there could instead be a “rotating schedule” of rabbis on call:
“If there is a need to have counseling...I think that the chaplains that were in the hospitals that my [family members] were in, it was nice that that was offered. But it would have been nicer if the rabbis also, you know, were especially where there's a major hospital...the local community [could] have...rabbis on call for that kind of thing...rabbis can't be on call 24/7 so it would be nice if they instituted some sort of a rotating schedule so that things are covered by someone...it's so much more comfortable in end-of-life settings to have your own people.”
One participant suggested that even in rural areas where it may be less feasible to have a rabbi on staff, there could still be education of other chaplains on the needs of Jewish patients:
“I'm not saying that every single hospital needs a Jewish chaplain because that's just unrealistic to expect especially in very, very rural places where there's not that many Jewish people at all. But there needs to be some kind of education from a chaplain or some other upper management person about the...basic expectations.”
Furthermore, interviews also revealed the need for greater access to kosher food in healthcare settings. As one participant put it, "I think it would be nice for those patients who keep kosher to have that as a meal option...if they can do it on airplanes, I don't see why they can't do it."
In addition to the need for greater religious accommodations in hospitals, participants also emphasized that hospital staff need to receive anti-bias training and trainings that focus on the specific needs and customs of Jewish patients. One participant explained, "I think that the experiences that I had could be corrected with combating the...ignorance...I don't think that those people were being malicious. I think they just had no idea what they were doing."
The experiences of the participants who had received a negative reaction from a provider around their decision to have a bris for their child, described earlier in this report, also revealed the need for greater cultural awareness and sensitivity to the religious customs of Jewish patients. As one of these participants explained, "I think like with the circumcision...I don't think you have to be told more than once that it's not medically needed. I thought that was just highly inappropriate."
One participant described feeling that after October 7, the healthcare field was not sufficiently sympathetic to the experiences of Jewish patients and expressed the need for proper training of healthcare staff:
“After October 7th, there was zero understanding and sympathy for Jewish patients, physicians, and healthcare workers...I think...there has to be formal training in antisemitism, period. That should be...training in unconscious bias, there needs to be formal training in antisemitism...you take an oath when you're a physician that you're going to treat everybody the same regardless.”
Another participant echoed this, saying that there’s a need to "educate the medical personnel about biases.” Another participant stressed the need to specifically train medical students, saying, “train those med students, that it has to be the med students, top-down.” In addition to bias-related trainings, one interviewee also described the need to train healthcare providers on the specific diseases and medical needs of Jewish patients, such as those specifically of Eastern European descent: “if they were more aware of diseases that are particularized to...Eastern European Jewish people.”
Finally, interviewees stressed the need for healthcare providers to maintain a firm commitment to equality and fair treatment for all patients, with several participants referencing the Hippocratic Oath. For instance, one participant said, "Basically when you take that [Hippocratic] Oath...you put your politics aside...You have to treat everyone...Jews, Zionists, antizionists, everyone...I just wish they would...instill that moral code." Similarly, another participant described the obligation that healthcare providers must treat all patients no matter their political or ethnic background:
“I think people need to just separate their politics like leave it at the door...I know hospitals are required to treat anyone if they come in even if they can't pay...that same framework needs to carry over if a Jewish person, if an Israeli person comes in, they need to treat them, and everything else should be irrelevant...it's the same with any other ethnic or racial group.”
A few participants expressed a similar sense that providers must not let politics impact their delivery of healthcare:
One interviewee referenced back to when his son became a physician and recited the Hippocratic Oath, to express that healthcare providers are obligated to provide equal and fair treatment for all patients:
“One of my sons is a physician...at the ceremony for them...graduating, they had to take not just the Hippocratic Oath...it doesn't matter whether you're talking about delivering [care] to Muslims or Jews, Blacks or Hispanics, or Asians...everybody deserves to be treated...with the highest level of ethical care...if...these [healthcare] establishments could...set the bar...”
In sum, participants identified several opportunities for the U.S. healthcare system to better meet the needs of Jewish patients. These included structural improvements, such as greater access to kosher food and chaplains knowledgeable about Jewish religious practices, as well as greater cultural and religious awareness among healthcare providers. Importantly, these findings suggest that meaningful inclusion requires more than the availability of specific accommodations; it also depends on whether Jewish patients can trust that their religious identities and needs will be understood, respected, and appropriately addressed throughout their care.
Conclusion
For Jewish patients, navigating the U.S. healthcare system can involve considerations that extend well beyond the quality of medical care. As the interviews in this study reveal, some Jewish patients find themselves weighing whether to disclose their Jewish identity, assessing the potential biases of healthcare providers, and questioning whether their religious and cultural needs will be respected. These concerns have become particularly pronounced for some patients since the October 7 Hamas attacks on Israel and the subsequent rise in antisemitism. Although the experiences of participants varied, and some described positive interactions with healthcare providers, the findings highlight an important challenge: Jewish patients should not have to choose between openly expressing their Jewish identity and feeling confident that they will receive safe, equitable and high-quality medical care.
The experiences documented in this report also underscore that barriers to Jewish patient inclusion can take many forms, ranging from insufficient religious accommodations and limited cultural awareness to perceived bias and overt hostility. Addressing these challenges requires both stronger institutional safeguards against antisemitism and greater attention to the religious and cultural needs of Jewish patients.
To this end, ADL, in partnership with the American Jewish Medical Association (AJMA), has outlined five key actions that hospitals and healthcare institutions can take to combat antisemitism and strengthen Jewish inclusion. These include explicitly identifying antisemitism, including antizionist harassment, as prohibited conduct in institutional nondiscrimination policies; establishing accessible and confidential mechanisms for reporting discrimination and harassment; requiring education and training on antisemitism and Jewish identity for medical professionals, staff and trainees; supporting Jewish employee resource groups and other institutional structures that elevate Jewish perspectives and concerns; and adopting and consistently enforcing robust religious accommodation policies.
These measures offer healthcare institutions a framework for translating commitments to nondiscrimination and inclusion into meaningful institutional practices.
Ultimately, the concerns raised by Jewish patients in this study speak to a fundamental principle of medical ethics: every patient deserves to receive healthcare free from discrimination, regardless of their religious identity, ethnic background or political beliefs. Although these interviews do not establish the prevalence of antisemitism across the U.S. healthcare system, they illuminate experiences and anxieties that warrant greater institutional attention. Building trust among Jewish patients requires more than affirming a general commitment to equality; it requires healthcare institutions to demonstrate through their policies, practices and everyday interactions that Jewish identity will never be a barrier to receiving compassionate, respectful and high-quality care.
No Jewish patient should have to wonder whether concealing their identity is necessary to protect their health or safety. Ensuring that patients can enter healthcare settings without facing this calculation is not only critical to Jewish patient inclusion, but also to upholding the foundational promise of equitable healthcare for all.
Methodology
This report draws on interviews with 40 Jewish people who have received healthcare services in the U.S. within the past five years. The age range of participants spanned from late 20s to 80s. Among the interviewees, 25 were women, 14 were men, and 1 identified with another gender identity. They were geographically dispersed and came from 15 states including New York, California, Colorado, North Carolina, Florida, Tennessee, Virginia, Washington, Minnesota, Indiana, Pennsylvania, New Jersey, Illinois, Connecticut, Vermont, and one lived abroad.
Interviews asked questions about participants’ comfort levels disclosing their Jewish identity to healthcare providers, what impacts their selection of healthcare providers, their experiences with antisemitism in healthcare, and what changes they would like to see in the healthcare system to better support Jewish patients. We recruited respondents through ADL’s vast network. Prior to beginning the study, we received Institutional Review Board (IRB) approval from Gratz College to conduct these interviews.